Things may be booming on Wall Street, but state governments' HR departments are still reeling from the Great Recession. They're facing personnel cuts, pay freezes and disappearing budgets—just as baby boomers begin to retire.
The challenges are ongoing as state leaders continue to cut HR budgets across the board. And as agencies race to fill vacant or soon-to-be-vacant positions, training programs often get slashed first, says Richard Greene, a principal with Barrett and Greene Inc., a New York-based research firm that studies state and local policy and management.
Why training programs? Greene, who has interviewed dozens of state HR leaders over the past several years, says internal cuts are the least likely to upset taxpayers.
"There's this whole debate over what makes the government work better versus how we can provide direct services to voters," he explains. "If we stop giving you the service we always have, people notice. If you want to cut back on mental health dollars, there's an affected constituency. But if you cut training, your constituency is just internal government workers."
A Lack of Demonstrated Impact
In addition to a lack of public exposure, training programs are vulnerable because they don't often yield measurable results. HR departments can't easily demonstrate the long-term value of investing in training.
"It would be ideal to show your state legislature that with more training, you'd need to hire fewer people, or productivity goes up 15 percent, or if we cut training we'll lose this much money," says Greene. "But they can't put it in concrete terms."
Imagine government HR leaders' frustration: According to our 2015 Human Capital Management Report(HCMG), leadership development is a crucial part of agencies' talent management strategies—with 63 percent of survey respondents marking it as a current concern, and 29 percent noting it as their top priority for ongoing staff development.
At the same time, a mere 2 percent of the HCMG survey respondents ranked their succession planning efforts as very successful (a 50 percent decrease from 4 percent in 2013), highlighting the wide gap between "strategy" and reality in leadership development for employees.
The Need for Shifted Priorities
Greene is quick to note that the ongoing cuts to government HR departments aren't a "nefarious plot" to keep HR managers at arm’s length from the real decision-makers. Instead, governments simply don't grasp the value or long-term return of investing in HR.
To more effectively communicate the value of training programs, HR departments should look closely at how they measure employee performance and tie in the impact of training, says Greene.
Of course, not every state leader takes his or her HR department for granted. Greene points to North Carolina Governor Pat McCrory as a state leader who values the importance of HR.
McCrory, who worked in the HR department at Duke Energy, told Greene that he chose his former boss, Neal Alexander, as the state's HR director because Alexander sought to elevate the department from an administrative function to one that had more say in strategic, statewide decisions.
McCrory says that Alexander's managerial experience as Vice President for Human Resources at Duke Energy, the country's largest electric power holding company, helps him understand "the importance of having HR at the table to understand the business issues that were being addressed in cabinet meetings and other secretary meetings throughout the organization."
With a talent crisis looming, other politicians would do well to follow McCrory's lead. Without understanding the true value of HR and investing resources in talent management, government leaders are putting the future of their agencies—and consequently, their workforces—at risk.
Photo: Shutterstock
Ressources similaires
Vous souhaitez continuer à apprendre ? Découvrez nos produits, les témoignages de nos clients et les actualités du secteur.
Témoignage de client
Des carrières axées compétences grâce à l'IA
Le groupe DHL est le leader mondial de la logistique. DHL se compose de plusieurs divisions commerciales très soudées qui travaillent en synergie pour répondre aux besoins des clients.
Témoignage de client
RPS met tout en œuvre pour simplifier la complexité
Présent dans 125 pays, RPS est un prestataire de services professionnels international spécialisé dans les environnements naturels et bâtis. La société emploie des collaborateurs de tous milieux, notamment des consultants, des universitaires, des scientifiques, des architectes et des ingénieurs. Jusqu'en 2018, les RH étaient décentralisées. Aucune stratégie mondiale n'était en place, le poste de directeur/directrice des ressources humaines n'avait pas été créé et plusieurs systèmes et processus manuels coexistaient.
Témoignage de client
Déployer une plateforme de contenus : l’expérience du groupe Delachaux
Permettre à tous les salariés de se former quand ils le veulent, comme ils le veulent : c’est ce que les plateformes de contenus digitales rendent aujourd’hui possible. Mais le rêve ne devient pas réalité en claquant des doigts : de la décision à l’appropriation par les utilisateurs, il y a bien des étapes à franchir. Les retours d’expérience restent le meilleur moyen de s’en faire une idée. Le Groupe Delachaux, par la voix de sa Learning & Development Manager Hong Nguyen, a détaillé lors d’un récent webinar le déploiement de la solution de Cornerstone Content Anytime.