If an employee reports harassment to their manager, is it the responsibility of the manager to report it to HR? What should if the employee doesn't want the complaint to go to HR, and the manager doesn't want to lose the employee's trust? And, what should a manager do if the employee describes the situation, but doesn't provides the name of the alleged harasser? Does a manager need to take any steps if an employee goes directly to HR and claims they don't want an investigation?
Reluctant to Report
When an employee comes to you with a complaint, the subject of the complaint is critical.
If your employee says, "I can't stand working with James because he's always talking about Minecraft and it drives me insane! Can you do something about it? And please, don't tell him I said anything," then you can decide how to best handle the situation. You can tell your complaining employee to suck it up. Alternatively, you can go to James and say, "Hey buddy, can you knock off the Minecraft talk?" without mentioning who brought it up. Or you can ignore the complainer entirely. Easy peasy.
It's not a big deal because a Minecraft discussion, while annoying to some, has no legal ramifications.
But, if your employee comes to you about racist jokes or sexual comments made by a colleague, then you've got a problem that you can't ignore. As a manager, you are now acting on behalf of your organization and once the company is aware of a problem, it has to act. If you ignore this or tell the person to suck it up, you are opening up the company to legal liability. Here's what you need to do to handle the harassment, while protecting the employee that reported it:
Follow Your Company's Procedures
Your company should have a spelled-out protocol for reporting illegal harassment complaints—follow it! Most likely, you're required to report the incident to your manager and/or the HR department. That's right, it's your responsibility to turn it over to HR, no matter what your employee requests.
Why can't you just handle it yourself? Because procedures need to be followed. This isn't just because your HR manager loves paperwork—it's because consistency is important when it comes to legal matters and ramifications. If you simply tell the accused to knock off his racist jokes and assume that the problem is taken care of, it seems like a decent solution until you find out that Sonja in another department was suspended for making racist jokes. Suddenly, you've made the company susceptible to a gender discrimination lawsuit from Sonja, since her punishment was more strict than James' for the same offense.
Tell the Reporting Employee Why You Must Involve HR
This is the hard part, but you'll have to be honest with the employee that brought the harassment to your attention. Try a dialogue like this: "Jane, I really appreciate you coming and telling me about this. We take sexual/racial/religious harassment very seriously. I know you want to keep this quiet, and I respect that. However, the company has to investigate your claims and solve the problem. I promise you that you will face no retaliation for coming forward, and we will do our best to protect your privacy."
Your employee may not like hearing that, and that's unfortunate. But, this is a situation where you can't respect an employee's request to do nothing.
The law and your company policies require action. When you report the problem to HR, make clear that you promised your employee that this would be handled in the most professional and confidential manner possible. That should be standard, but it never hurts to remind people.
Suzanne Lucas, Evil HR Lady
Photo: Creative Commons
Want to keep learning? Explore our products, customer stories, and the latest industry insights.
Honoring Black excellence in the workplace and beyond
The month of February is Black History Month — an annual celebration to recognize the history of African-American achievements in the USA. During this month’s observance, we commemorate Black excellence and pivotal African-American figures like Arthur Ashe, Sojourner Truth, Phillis Wheatley and Victor Glover.
DEIB: Designing for a Post-Pandemic World
Many organizations still have a long way to go when it comes to diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging (DEIB). This study, based on a review of more than 70 articles and interviews with 10 DEIB leaders and 20 HR leaders, answers several critical questions:
Cultivate a culture of belonging with conversational learning
People learn best from one another by actively engaging in sensitive dialogues and listening to different perspectives, even if they have different backgrounds and beliefs. Yet many organizations struggle with implementing diversity programs that successfully affect behavioral change and increase shareholder value. Research has shown that compulsory diversity training sometimes does more harm than good, resulting in hostility and resistance toward opposing views.